Jun 14
2009
States as Incubators
In response to a post from Matthew Cooper over at The Atlantic about the possibility of the FDA overseeing the tobacco industry, Crooked Timber examines the economics of the world's smoking bans.
While all of that is quite interesting, it was the following quote from The Atlantic that I found fascinating. In response to the incredible popularity of smoking bans after New York City instituted theirs in 2004, Cooper writes, "Consider it part of the beauty of federalism. The small ideas that incubate in laboratories of democracy, as the former Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis famously called the states, have grown wildly." While this may be a well known idea, I had never really thought of states as the incubators for new ideas that may move up to a national level. Very interesting.
Tags: economics, politics, smoking
there is a long tradition of this especially for civil rights cases. It was the state by state strategy that led to breakthroughs like desegregation, and is now being used by advocates for universal marriage rights. The tactic works because it appeals to both parties, republicans advocate for small government and can't really argue with state legislation, incubation gives big government democrats the evidence they need to push for federal legislation. It is a prime example of our system of government working effectively. For more on the legislation and the effect of the NY ban i suggest this video: http://www.newsy.com/videos/new_sheriff_in_town